Management Team

Our Management Team is united by a commitment to mutuality, and the economic well-being of local communities. With extensive experience across multiple sectors of the banking industry, we work in conjunction with our affiliates’ own management teams and boards of directors, making decisions that are in the best interests of customers
Headshot of Thomas J. Fraser
Thomas J. Fraser
CEO, First Mutual Holding Co.
Thomas J. Fraser | CEO, First Mutual Holding Co.
Headshot of Paul V. Capka
Paul V. Capka
SVP, Chief Credit Officer
Paul V. Capka | SVP, Chief Credit Officer
Headshot of Nancy Marie Dixon
Nancy Marie Dixon
SVP, Digital Innovations Officer
Nancy Marie Dixon | SVP, Digital Innovations Officer
Headshot of Debra Kaput
Debra Kaput
SVP, Chief Human Resources Officer
Debra Kaput | SVP, Chief Human Resources Officer
Headshot of Carl A. Kessler III
Carl A. Kessler III
SVP, Chief Information Officer
Carl A. Kessler III | SVP, Chief Information Officer
Headshot of Brian J. Pinkerton
Brian J. Pinkerton
SVP, Corporate Governance & Risk Officer
Brian J. Pinkerton | SVP, Corporate Governance & Risk Officer
Headshot of Jennifer A. Raynor
Jennifer A. Raynor
SVP, Chief Communications & Culture Officer
Jennifer A. Raynor | SVP, Chief Communications & Culture Officer
Headshot of David T. Shaw
David T. Shaw
SVP, Chief Administration Officer & Secretary
David T. Shaw | SVP, Chief Administration Officer & Secretary
Headshot of Mary Ann Stropkay
Mary Ann Stropkay
President, Fee-Based Businesses
Mary Ann Stropkay | President, Fee-Based Businesses